The Transformers Archive Skip to main content / Also skip section headers

[The Transformers Archive - an international fan site]
Please feel free to log in or register.

 
  • transformers toys
  • transformers comics
  • transformers cartoon
  • transformers live-action movies
  • transformers fandom
  • transformers forum

Go Back   TFARCHIVE > TRANSFORMERS > Transformers Media & Fandom > Site Media Reviews

Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread
Old 2014-08-01, 10:41 PM   #1
Red Dave Prime
Assistant Comic Reviewer
 
Red Dave Prime's Avatar
 
Ireland
Default Comic Review: Robots in Disguise #3 [uploaded]

Robots in Disguise #3
Stick Together

Published Date: March 28 2012
Written by:
John Barber
Art by: Andrew Griffith
Colours by: Josh Perez
Edited by: Carlos Guzman
Cover price: $3.99

Summary
Silverbolt leads the Aerialbots to a rendezvous with Prowl and his security team as they remove the body of Ratbat from the Decepticon base. Prowl tries to convince the assembled Decepticons that Ratbat's death was a suicide but they aren't accepting it. Starscream tries to help by backing up Prowl's story but it doesn't convince the 'cons, especially an irate Dirge who storms off in disgust at the Autobots' attempt at a cover-up. Barrel Roll (you know, the sixth Aerialbot) tries to calm him down but before he can save the situation a massive explosion occurs, destroying Barrel Roll and sending many robots flying, Dirge included.

Sifting through the rubble in the aftermath of the blast, Wheeljack conducts an investigation while Metalhawk and Prowl clash over who gets the blame. Wheeljack theories that it was an extremely high temperature explosion of some sort given the heat involved but rules out a nuke given the blast radius. Metalhawk laments the damage the war has obviously done to his home world. Nine fatalities are recorded. Two Autobot, Seven Neutrals, but no Decepticons which pushes Prowls suspicions further. 'Bee, Metalhawk and Prowl go to confront Starscream but he is ready for them with a counter that the explosion highlights the poor safe housing situation on Cybertron.
Seeking answers, Wheeljack heads to the infirmary to talk to Dirge, given how close he was to the epicentre of the blast. He finds the Decepticon in little mood to co-operate and things get worse when an enraged Silverbolt tries to force the answers from Dirge. While Wheeljack tries to settle the situation, elsewhere in the city another blast occurs causing more damage.

Heading to the blast zone, Wheeljack encounters Starscream and the two quarrel about finding a solution. Starscream points out that Wheeljack needs to get his priorities in line - it's about Cybertronians, not Autobots now. Starscream brings up his seekers in the discussion which leads Wheeljack to name a few of them, including Thundercracker - and the breakthrough occurs. Wheeljack realises that the problem is because there is no second moon orbiting Cybertron anymore to help balance the flow of energy from the planet to the moons that normally revolve around it. This is causing the energy to superheat the atmosphere causing the massive explosions. With this new data, Wheeljack concludes that another explosion is imminent and its location will be the centre of the city. Both come up with plans to save the day.

Back at the Autobot HQ Prowl informs Bumblebee of the situation, but before the little yellow guy can over-react, Wheeljack informs them that he and Starscream have solved the problem. Starscream has taken the neutrals to the Kima facility as this can withstand the high levels of heat, while Wheeljack has engineered some missiles to help attract the energy away from the planet until he can create a permeant satellite solution. Sure enough, the missiles help direct the explosion away from the planet.

In the aftermath of all the drama, Wheeljack explains the Bumblebee that Starscream was as much the hero as he was. He stresses the importance of all of them working together but just as Bumblebee is about to agree, Silverbolt appears and strikes him to the ground. The Aerialbot commander is disgusted by his fellow Autobots working with their mortal enemy and he denounces the new government leads the Aerialbots into the wilderness.

Characters (in rough order of appearance)
Silverbolt, Barrel Roll, Skydive, Air Raid, Slingshot, Fireflight, Triggerhappy, Needlenose, Blurr, Prowl, Sideswipe, Bombshell, Hook, Fixit, Streetwise, Ratbat (corpse), Mixmaster, Motormaster, Starscream, Blot, Mindwipe, Dirge, Dead End, Ransack, Wheeljack, Tappet, Hipotank, Bumblebee, Hot Spot, Bonecrusher, Metalhawk, Scattershot, Broadside, Arcee, Ironhide

Notes
Barrel Roll is, of course, isn't one of the original five Aerialbots. He was originally a Minicon although not expressly part of the Armada / Energon universe.

Dirge's gripe with the Autobots and Decepticons comes from the events in All Hail Megatron where he and Deluge were stranded with Autobot prisoners on an Insecticon-filled Cybertron. It's implied that Deluge didn't survive the event.

Thrust's death at the hands of Humans in All Hail Megatron #16 is confirmed. Oddly the Wiki mentions the death occurring in Spotlight: Prowl but the only mention there is of a red and black jet where as in AHM #16 we specifically see Thrust (and he is in pretty bad shape).

Ramjet's death at the hands of Megatron is also alluded to (see Spotlight: Ramjet)

The missing moon of Cybertron is Luna 1 and its disappearance was first brought up in MTMTE #1. It will be found in MTMTE #18.

Quote / Unquote
"Donít get me started on King Bee and this hunk of rust he calls a city. Cities have infrastructure" - Wheeljack bemoans the shambles of a city that all the transformers are living in.

"Why assume it was a Decepticon?"
"Gee Metalhawk, every event of every day of the last six million years mostly" - Metalhawk asks a silly question, Gets a Prowl slap in the face.

"There hasn't been a disaster like this for as long as I can remember. What have you done to our world?" - Metalhawks observation may have made more impact if we didn't already know about Thunderwing, the many different Decepticon attacks and Chaos. Nine casualties does not seem that big set against many of those events

"I remember you. You - You kicked me." - If he was a Beast Wars character, Dirge would be an elephant

"I have no idea what you're saying." - Starscream may be many thinks, but a scientist he isn't.

"We fought his kind for years and this is the reward you give us? A planet thatís trying to kill us - and Decepticons at our side?" - Silverbolt is not happy with the new order of things.

Review
It's funny reviewing a comic where you can see so many little faults with what's going on, but yet still enjoy the main story running through it. This is one such comic. RID #3 contains some terrible character moments, awful dialogue (mostly contained within the audio of Metalhawk) and forced actions but I still like the overall simplicity of Wheeljack having a problem - and fixing it. In this case itís the surrounding, over-arching plot lines that irritate and not because they're particularly bad but because they feel a bit too forced. Much like some of the off-beat character moments from last issue, this issue has one or two moments which just seem too unlikely.

As I said in the last review, I would leave comments on Ratbat's assassination at the hands of Arcee to this issue and the main reason is that this issue features the Autobot explanation and the reaction of the Decepticons. And itís a bit of a mess. Ratbat was found pinned to the wall by an energon sword. He was discovered by a fellow Decepticon. There is simply no way at all that this could be painted as a suicide. If Prowl wants to cover up what happened there is no way that Mr. Logic would pick the least likely answer. He could have gone with an outside neutral wanting vengeance for the treatment of fellow neutrals at the hands of the Decepticons. He could have gone with a fellow Decepticon making a power play. But instead he picks the least plausible scenario possible when dealing with a one winged bat pinned to the wall. It must be suicide!

The thing is, it's never clear what he is covering up. He never gave Arcee an order to kill (in fact last issue he seemed specific on trying to arrest Ratbat as opposed to killing him). Arcee isn't an Autobot. And no-one else knows Arcee is there (she isn't seen at the crime and seems to be in hiding). So why the lie? I'm guessing it's because Barber wants the Decepticons to feel that they are being repressed and lied to which allows Metalhawk to see things from their side. But it doesn't work and feels forced.

Ah, Metalhawk. Ok, We get that he represents the suspicious side of the returning Cybertronians and that they feel that both sides were as equally responsible for what happened to cause the exodus and the damage to Cybertron. But his character simply doesn't hold up. It's inconceivable that this self-appointed leader wouldn't check up on some history since he has left. He complains about the state of the planet but in reality Cybertron's main damage was done by the destruction of the Toraxxis refinery (Decepticon), Thunderwing (Decepticon), the Swarm (Decepticon) and the Decepti-god (Decepticon - more or less). This kind of blinkered view feels, once again, forced. Barber wants a character to make a certain stance but can't come up with a realistic reason to establish that. Metalhawk, who is a pretty miserable character so far anyway, is playing the role normally assigned to humans - that of being an observer of Autobots and Decepticons and yet can only come to the conclusion that ALL robots are equally bad. It doesn't work with Human characters and it doesn't work with Metalhawk (or the other neutrals for that matter). Things aren't helped by Metalhawk's comments - claiming that the nine fatalities are anywhere in the same league as Zeta Prime's Omega Destructors and the Vamparc Cannon, the destruction of Nyon by Hot Rod and the Toraxxis tragedy is clearly off - and Metalhawk was there for all of these events. One final niggle in all this - Metalhawk is basing his displeasure of the Autobots mostly on what they were before Optimus and how they failed they end the war in the initial rise of the Decpticons. Six million years pass and thatís his basis for his current antagonism.

Ok, so after all that complaining, you may be wondering why I do still like this issue. There's three reasons. The first is the plot. As I said, it's simple enough but it's still interesting as the cause of the explosions isn't immediately obvious but the reveal makes sense as does the solution. Thatís a little achievement in sci-fi these days to be honest. I also like how as a plot it's started and ended in the same issue with the ongoing issues carrying along the bigger picture (even if I don't have much love for them). It's something that both RID and MTMTE bring to the table which is new to the IDW run. Stories aren't now based around a 6 part run which can be wrapped up in a TPB as we saw during Furman and McCarthy's runs. We had a few glimpses of the stand-alone issues in Costa's run and it's no surprise that they were the best issues he did.

Another great part of this issue is the interplay between Wheeljack and Starscream. It's well done, it evolves both characters with Starscream backing up his changed stance from last issue and Wheeljack accepting of his mortal enemy and possibly appreciating someone else finding a solution to a problem. Both characters are engaging and interesting and should be the stars going forward. Dirge is also given a little bit of a spotlight and shines in a manner that only Dirge can. He is so far more sympathetic than any of the poor NAILs. Bumblebee calms down a bit from the psycho vibes of the last two issues and mostly plays as a good counter to Prowl. Silverbolt sadly seems to have taken on 'Bee's psycho tendencies and his flipping out to get at Dirge, coupled with his reaction at the end is perhaps a little overplayed. As for Barrel Roll, we knew he was dead once he identified himself as the only Aerialbot who wouldnít form part of Superion.

Finally, I have to give kudos to the art. I may not be a fan of Griffiths faces in general but he has some really nice artwork in this issue and its helped a lot by Josh Perez's colours. They help bring a vibrancy and clarity to the overall issue meaning that crowd issues never look too cluttered and stand out moments do what they should. The initial bomb blast and the missiles engaging the energy pulse are both excellent (save for Arcees horror visage appearing in a little circle, just to annoy me it would seem). And while Arcee's face is still the stuff of nightmares, Griffiths does well with Wheeljack. Given that he only has two eyes to work with, he gets a good bit of expression from the Autobot. I also dig the chunky design of Wheeljack - it doesn't suit Starscream but on many of the Autobots it works well. One final bit of love for my Wheeljack art love-in is Cover A (also by Griffith) It's lovely and I was always annoyed that I got the somewhat lesser Casey Coller Starscream one, which is still good but not as endearing as Griffiths.

So three issues in and Robots in Disguise has been a somewhat pleasant surprise. Problems aside, they've been three decent enough issues and I really like parts of Issue one and three. Next up though is a big one as a seed will be planted that will cast a shadow over the next year and more of RID.

Rating: 3.5 Energon Cubes out of 5 (if I could go 3.75 I probably would)
 

Last edited by Blackjack; 2014-08-03 at 10:46 AM.
Red Dave Prime is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2014-08-02, 09:44 PM   #2
Blackjack
Unashamed Movie Fanboy
 
Blackjack's Avatar
 
Default

Proofread this. Issue 3 was a really mixed bag for me. It's one of those things where the really bad things stand out (and I know it's going to get worse, not better), which is a shame since the general concept holds some promise and there are some good parts. To a lesser extent this is how I feel about Regeneration One, except that the bad things stand out much, much worse and the good parts really come off short compared to RID.

Wheeljack's design looks good because unlike Bumblebee, Starscream etc he doesn't use a War for Cybertron design. And good god Silverbolt and Air Raid brings their WFC bodies into pay and Silverbolt's is really horribly ugly and doesn't look like him at all. Starscream's is particularly ugly as well.

Do like the visual effects of Blurr zipping around that crater.

Wheeljack was great fun, and definitely the highlight of the episode! I thought this one issue focus on Wheeljack made it so much more bearable, and the focus of some random explosions killing people is a nice little filler issue similar to, oh, the Sparkeater from MTMTE or Thundercracker from Mike Costa. Moves the plot forward while having a single episode that resolves itself in the end.

I also do like how Dirge's non-traditional characterization as an estranged Decepticon was given some excuse thanks to his backstory in AHM. It's not like, oh, Silverbolt who gets up from bed one day and decides to be a psychotic fanatic for no reason.

Starscream is still neither here nor there, but at least we knew he did something to earn the NAILs' respect.

I hate the Ratbat bit too. It doesn't make sense, and I personally still hate Ratbat being killed.

Good lord, Silverbolt is a dick. I never remembered this scene. Hell, I never even remembered Silverbolt showing up anywhere in the series beyond SUDDENLY SUPERION. No wonder I exorcised that scene from my head -- it's horrible. You'd think that it would be better served by having the Dinobots flip out -- Slag or Swoop would certainly feel far more appropriate in this situation, especially since they did lost Grimlock thanks to Autobot bureaucracy, and they're going to go to the wilderness anyway.

Bumblebee's a dick. Also an idiot. Why doesn't he just go to Metalhawk and go 'look, here's what the Decepticons did. See this? This is footage of the Seekers blowing up Earth. Blah blah blah.' Instead of going all 'grawr Starscream evil I blow up Horri-Bull's head and I act like a dick to Starscream without giving evidence while Starscream is being all nice'. You're a dumbass, Bumblebee. Stay dead. Leave being Bumblebee to people who aren't morons.

Metalhawk's a dick. Man, he's such a massive dick. In addition to being a massive idiot like you said in the review, Metalhawk is such an unsympathetic dick who goes around being high and mighty. I totally agree with Prowl and Bumblebee and even Starscream, but Metalhawk is such a self-righteous, entitled little shit that ends up making the arguments he's making make no sense. I want to punch him in the face. He's nowhere as bad as Costa's Spike, but rereading these RID stories I think Metalhawk's shot up to being my least favourite character in the IDW universe.

There are so many dicks in this series.
 
Blackjack is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:29 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
 
 
[the-hub.co.uk]
[transfans.co.uk]
[oneshallstand]
[unicron.com]
[counter-x.net]
[ntfa.net]
[allspark.com]
[transformertoys.co.uk]
[tfu.info]
[botchthecrab.com]
[obscure_tf]
[tfradio.net]
 

[TFArchive button]
Link graphics...

BOOKMARK US
Or in FF, hit Ctrl+D.